| 1950 | Jim Lesher, defensive line |
| 1961 | Doug Donoho, linebacker Tom Finn, defensive line Bob Halsey, quarterback Jim Nelson, center Ervin Olson, running back Dave Werner, defensive back |
| 1962 | Dave Fink, defensive end John Gavurnik, defensive line Ervin Olson, fullback Jim Payne, running back Larry Reinhold, quarterback Gene Schrader, offensive line and linebacker Pat Schrader, wide receiver |
| 1963 | Dave Fink, defensive end John Gavurnik, defensive line Al Hopkins, offensive line Jim Payne, running back Larry Reinhold, quarterback Gene Schrader, linebacker Pat Schrader, wide receiver Richard Snyder, defensive line Al Thom, defensive back |
| 1964 | Dave Fink, defensive end Carroll Hickenbottom, running back Don Lahti, defensive back Norm Matzl, offensive line |
| 1965 | Paul Lynch, wide receiver Ron Reeves, defensive line Sidney Truckenbrod, offensive line |
| 1966 | Gary Fink, offensive guard Tom Fugette, fullback Don Lahti, linebacker Ron Reeves, defensive guard Norberto Simpson, running back John Wetterling, tight end |
| 1967 | Bob Anacker, offensive and defensive line Bill Heinkel, running back Dick Laba, defensive back Bob Raleigh, linebacker Ralph Vaughn, wide receiver |
| 1968 | Bill Heinkel, running back Dick Laba, defensive back Gary Lawell, defensive tackle Bill Radakovitz, offensive tackle |
| 1969 | Scott Boren, offensive end Dan Cassity, defensive tackle Mike Droese, linebacker Dick Laba, defensive back Rich Massat, center Gary Peterson, offensive guard Bill Radakovitz, offensive tackle Frank Rus, linebacker John Sobczak, fullback |
| 1970 | Dan Cassity, defensive tackle Mike Droese, linebacker Roger Klein, defensive end Dick Laba, defensive back Rich Massat, center Gary Peterson, offensive guard Frank Rus, linebacker Curt Whipple, defensive back |
| 1971 | Dan Cassity, defensive tackle Craig Deaton, quarterback Dave Dorak, defensive back Tom Holt, running back Bernie Jones, offensive tackle Gary Peterson, offensive guard Fred Richter, tight end Frank Rus, linebacker Curt Whipple, running back |
| 1972 | Randy Converse, defensive end Terry Converse, linebacker Dave Dorak, defensive back Jim Jodat, running back Mike Kuffel, offensive guard Joe Paricka, offensive tackle |
| 1973 | Randy Converse, defensive end Terry Converse, linebacker Jim Jodat, running back Mike Kuffel, offensive guard Chuck Malek, linebacker Andrew Zanin, defensive back |
| 1974 | John Blackburn Terry Converse, linebacker Jim Jodat, running back Tim Konicek |
| 1975 | Jim Jodat, running back Mike Levonowich, defensive tackle |
| 1977 | Dave Doering, center Mike Hopkins, defensive tackle Mike Slaughter, running back Ray Threlkeld, defensive back |
| 1978 | Tim Roets, defensive end Ray Threlkeld, wide receiver |
| 1979 | Tim Roets, linebacker |
| 1980 | Tim Roets, linebacker Steve Ganzel, offensive guard Rick Kehr, offensive tackle Tom Aldrich, running back John O’Connor, kick returner Tim Roets, linebacker |
| 1981 | Bob Aslan, running back Vince Christy, tight end, Karl Hipchen, linebacker Curt Karas, defensive line Chuck Krey, offensive guard Darrell Palmer, defensive back Tim Rucks, offensive tackle |
| 1982 | Bob Aslan, running back Karl Hipchen, linebacker Darrell Palmer, defensive back |
| 1983 | George Schwamberger |
| 1984 | Lloyd Griffin, kicker |
| 1985 | Pete Baranek, running back |
| 1986 | Jim Bentz, defensive tackle Todd Miller, offensive guard |
| 1987 | Jim Bentz, defensive tackle |
| 1988 | Bob Bentz, defensive tackle Corey Jefferson, defensive back |
| 1989 | Shawn Feuker, defensive tackle |
| 1990 | Shawn Feuker, defensive tackle Chris Harper, running back |
| 1991 | Shawn Feuker, defensive line |
| 1993 | Tim Evans, linebacker Tim Gatz, wide receiver |
| 1996 | Kevin Burris, running back |
| 1997 | Kevin Burris, running back Paul Hoffman, center John Sedeska, linebacker |
| 1998 | Kevin Burris, running back Terry Filippis, tight end Paul Hoffman, center John Sedeska, linebacker |
| 1999 | Kevin Burris, running back Jack Prall, defensive back |
| 2000 | Rob Garnes, wide receiver |
| 2001 | Randal Baker, running back Ray Hartmann, defensive end |
| 2002 | Randal Baker, running back Ray Hartmann, linebacker |
| 2003 | Jon Binish, offensive line Mike Pelkowski, linebacker Dante Washington, running back |
| 2004 | Brett Barnes, defensive back Jon Binish, offensive line Brandon Fox, linebacker Jason Kalinowski, defensive line Donovan Moore, punter Mike Pelkowski, linebacker Dante Washington, running back |
| 2005 | Michael Anderson, defensive line Donovan Moore, defensive back/punter Mike Pelkowski, defensive line |
| 2006 | Ryan Glassman, offensive line |
| 2007 | Bryan Bergman, tight end Donovan Moore, defensive back/punter Franko Shenault, defensive back Matt Denny, kicker |
| 2008 | Alex Annes, defensive end Jeff Koeneman, wide receiver |
| 2009 | Terrance Clark, offensive line Tyler Funk, punter Jeff Koeneman, wide receiver Nick Merchut, wide receiver |
| 2010 | Terrance Clark, offensive line Evan Jones, quarterback Tyler Funk, kicker/punter Brian Hipchen, defensive back Chris Schulz, wide receiver |
| 2011 | Brad Fortney, linebacker |
| 2012 | Brett Bukari, kicker Tyler O’Brien, defensive end |
| 2015 | Terrance Allen, defensive end Jacob Alten, offensive line K.J. Simpson, linebacker |