Augustana (Ill.) 39, St. Norbert 32, first round
Mount Union 42, Augustana (Ill.) 33, second round
2000
Ohio Northern 47, Millikin 21, first round
2001
Augustana 54, Defiance 14, first round
Mount Union 32, Augustana (Ill.) 7, second round
2002
Wheaton (Ill.) 42, Alma 14, first round
Mount Union 42, Wheaton (Ill.) 21, second round
Â
2003
Wheaton (Ill.) 55, Hope 45, first round
Wheaton (Ill.) 16, Baldwin-Wallace 12, second round
Mount Union 56, Wheaton (Ill.) 10, quarterfinals
2004
Carthage 31, Alma 28, first round
Carthage 14, Wooster 7, second round
Mount Union 38, Carthage 20, quarterfinals
Wheaton (Ill.) 31, Mount St. Joseph 7, first round
Mount Union 26, Wheaton (Ill.) 7, second round
Â
2005
Augustana (Ill.) 49, Lakeland 22, first round
Mount Union 44, Augustana (Ill.) 7, second round
Capital 21, North Central 19, first round
2006
North Central 35, Concordia (Wis.), first round
Capital 41, North Central 13, second round
Wheaton (Ill.) 42, Mount St. Joseph 28, first round
Mount Union 35, Wheaton (Ill.) 3, second round
2007
North Central 44, Franklin 42, first round
Wisconsin-Whitewater 59, North Central 28, second round
Wheaton (Ill.) 14, Trine 0, first round
Wheaton (Ill.) 59, Wabash 28, second round
Wheaton (Ill.) 45, Franklin 28, quarterfinals
Mount Union 45, Wheaton (Ill.) 24, semifinals
2008
North Central (Ill.) 44, Thomas More, first round
Franklin 38, North Central (ill.) 28, second round
Wheaton (Ill.) 14, Trine 0, first round
Wheaton (Ill.) 59, Wabash 28 in the second round
Wheaton (Ill.) 45, Franklin 28 in the quarterfinals
Mount Union 45, Wheaton (Ill. 24 in the semifinals
2009
Illinois Wesleyan 41, Wabash 35 (2 OT), first round
Wisconsin-Whitewater 45, Illinois Wesleyan 7, second round
2010
North Central (Ill.) 59, St. Norbert 7, first round
Wheaton (Ill.) 31, Coe 21, first round
North Central (Ill.) 28, Ohio Northern 9, second round
Bethel (Minn.) 15, Wheaton (Ill.) 10, second round
Wisconsin-Whitewater 20, North Central (Ill.) 10, quarterfinals
2011
Monmouth 33, Illinois Wesleyan 27 (3 OT), first round
North Central (Ill.) 59, Dubuque 13, first round
Wabash 29, North Central (Ill.) 28, second round
2012
Elmhurst 27, Coe 24, first round
North Central (Ill.) 41, California Lutheran 21, first round
Linfield 30, North Central (Ill.) 14, second round
St. Thomas (Minn.) 24, Elmhurst 17, second round
2013
Wartburg 41, Illinois Wesleyan 7, first round
North Central (Ill.) 63, Albion 7, first round
North Central (Ill.) 52, Wisconsin-Platteville 24, second round
North Central (Ill.) 41, Bethel (Minn.) 17, quarterfinals
Mount Union 41, North Central (Ill.) 40, semifinals
2014
Wheaton (Ill.) 43, Benedictine (Ill) 14, first round
John Carroll 14, Wheaton (Ill.) 12, second round
2015
Lakeland 6, Wheaton (Ill.) 55, first round
UW-Whitewater 31, Wheaton (Ill.) 17 second round
2016
North Central (Ill.) 41, Rose-Hulman 7, first round
Wheaton (Ill.) 45, Huntingdon 10, first round
Wheaton 31 (Ill.), North Central (Ill.) 14, second round
Mary Hardin-Baylor 38, Wheaton (Ill.) 16, quarterfinals
2017
Case Western Reserve 28, Illinois Wesleyan 0, first round
North Central 17, St. John (Minn.) 7, first round
UW-Oshkosh 42, North Central 21, second round