Skip To Main Content
Skip To Main Content

Carthage College Athletics

The Official Website of The Carthage College Firebirds

Illinois Wesleyan (9-11, 0-3 CCIW) -VS- Carthage (15-9, 1-1 CCIW)

Box Score

Illinois Wesleyan logo
0
vs
Carthage logo
3

Illinois Wesleyan (9-11, 0-3 CCIW)
-VS-
Carthage (15-9, 1-1 CCIW)

Team Score By Period
Team 1 2 3
Illinois Wesleyan IWU 15 20 10
Winner Carthage CARTHAGE 25 25 25
Date:
10/8/2013
Time:
7 p.m.
Site:
Kenosha, Wis. (Tarble Arena)
Attendance:
175
Officials
1st Referee: Mike Immel
2nd Referee: Nancy Nester
VIEW
Match History vs Illinois Wesleyan

Match Details

Game Statistics By Set
Set Illinois Wesleyan Carthage
K E TA % K E TA %
Set #1 9 8 27 .037 9 3 21 .286
Set #2 14 8 46 .130 15 4 39 .282
Set #3 6 9 32 -.094 12 2 24 .417
Total 29 25 105 .038 36 9 84 .321
Team Statistical Comparison
Statistic Team Comparison
IWU - CARTHAGE
Points
32.0
47.0
Kills
29
36
Aces
3
7
Blocks
0
4
Assists
27
36
Digs
32
44

Game Leaders

IWU - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Greybar,Maddie (10), Schweigert, Kinzie (6), Howard,Morgan (4)
Aces Greybar,Maddie (1), Wachtel,Erin (1), Hawk,Lizzy (1)
Blocks
Assists Wachtel,Erin (18), Bruer, Lauren (4), Stenson, Morgan (3)
Digs Bruer, Lauren (16), Greybar,Maddie (7), Wachtel,Erin (4)
CARTHAGE - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Hailey, Bria (13), Staudinger, Anne (7), Mickey, Rachel (6)
Aces Cahoon, Hanna (4), Fields, Rachel (1), Staudinger, Anne (1)
Blocks Mickey, Rachel (2), Heuermann, Emily (2), Chin, Karen (1)
Assists Chin, Karen (32), Hailey, Bria (2), Fields, Rachel (1)
Digs Cahoon, Hanna (20), Fields, Rachel (7), Shumaker, Sara (5)

Individual Statistics

Illinois Wesleyan (9-11, 0-3 CCIW)

IWU - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
1 1 Howard,Morgan 3 4 5 16 -.063 0 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 1 0 0 0 4.0
5 5 Greybar,Maddie 3 10 6 32 .125 1 0 1 0 1-0 0 0 0 7 0 2 11.0
7 7 Wachtel,Erin 3 2 3 6 -.167 18 0 1 0 1-0 0 0 0 4 1 0 3.0
13 13 Knowels, Emily 3 4 3 12 .083 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4.0
15 15 Stenson, Morgan 3 2 4 11 -.182 3 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 2 0 0 2.0
19 19 Schweigert, Kinzie 3 6 2 22 .182 0 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 1 0 0 6.0
6 6 Sabino,Sydney 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0.0
17 17 Bruer, Lauren 3 1 1 4 .000 4 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 16 0 3 1.0
8 8 Hawk,Lizzy 2 0 1 2 -.500 0 0 1 0 1-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1.0
3 3 Adams,Tara 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
4 4 Thalmann,Miya 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
10 10 Udelhofen,Sarah 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0.0
20 20 Cornish, Alexa 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0
TM TM TEAM 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
Totals 29 25 105 .038 27 0 3 4 3-4 0 0 1 32 1 7 32
IWU - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
1 1 Howard,Morgan 3 0 0 1 0 0 0 4.0
5 5 Greybar,Maddie 3 0 0 0 7 0 2 11.0
7 7 Wachtel,Erin 3 0 0 0 4 1 0 3.0
13 13 Knowels, Emily 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 4.0
15 15 Stenson, Morgan 3 0 0 0 2 0 0 2.0
19 19 Schweigert, Kinzie 3 0 0 0 1 0 0 6.0
6 6 Sabino,Sydney 3 0 0 0 1 0 1 0.0
17 17 Bruer, Lauren 3 0 0 0 16 0 3 1.0
8 8 Hawk,Lizzy 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 1.0
3 3 Adams,Tara 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
4 4 Thalmann,Miya 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
10 10 Udelhofen,Sarah 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0.0
20 20 Cornish, Alexa 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0
TM TM TEAM 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
Totals 0 0 1 32 1 7 32

Carthage (15-9, 1-1 CCIW)

CARTHAGE - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
3 3 Shumaker, Sara 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0.0
9 9 Chin, Karen 3 2 0 3 .667 32 0 0 0 0-0 0 1 0 1 0 1 2.5
10 10 Mickey, Rachel 3 6 0 6 1.000 0 0 0 0 0-0 1 1 0 1 0 0 7.5
11 11 Fields, Rachel 3 3 2 15 .067 1 0 1 0 1-0 0 0 0 7 0 1 4.0
17 17 Staudinger, Anne 3 7 3 23 .174 0 0 1 2 1-2 1 0 1 4 0 0 9.0
18 18 Hailey, Bria 3 13 1 21 .571 2 0 1 0 1-0 0 0 0 2 0 0 14.0
1 1 Cahoon, Hanna 3 1 0 1 1.000 1 0 4 1 4-1 0 0 0 20 0 0 5.0
8 8 Domalewski, Anna 3 0 1 1 -1.000 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 2 0 1 0.0
12 12 Heuermann, Emily 3 4 2 14 .143 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 2 0 2 0 0 5.0
TM TM Team 0 0 -
Totals 36 9 84 .321 36 0 7 3 7-3 2 4 1 44 0 3 47
CARTHAGE - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
3 3 Shumaker, Sara 3 0 0 0 5 0 0 0.0
9 9 Chin, Karen 3 0 1 0 1 0 1 2.5
10 10 Mickey, Rachel 3 1 1 0 1 0 0 7.5
11 11 Fields, Rachel 3 0 0 0 7 0 1 4.0
17 17 Staudinger, Anne 3 1 0 1 4 0 0 9.0
18 18 Hailey, Bria 3 0 0 0 2 0 0 14.0
1 1 Cahoon, Hanna 3 0 0 0 20 0 0 5.0
8 8 Domalewski, Anna 3 0 0 0 2 0 1 0.0
12 12 Heuermann, Emily 3 0 2 0 2 0 0 5.0
TM TM Team 0
Totals 2 4 1 44 0 3 47

Play By Play

Set #1 Plays

Set #1 Plays
Serve Team IWU - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score CARTHAGE - Play Description
-- IWU subs: Bruer, Lauren.
-- CARTHAGE subs: Cahoon, Hanna.
CARTHAGE 0 Carthage 1 [Cahoon, Hanna] Attack error by Howard,Morgan (block by Staudinger, Anne).
CARTHAGE [Cahoon, Hanna] Bad set by Shumaker, Sara. 1 Illinois Wesleyan 1
IWU [Stenson, Morgan] Kill by Schweigert, Kinzie (from Greybar,Maddie). 2 Illinois Wesleyan 1
IWU [Knowels, Emily] Kill by Schweigert, Kinzie (from Bruer, Lauren). 3 Illinois Wesleyan 1
CARTHAGE 3 Carthage 2 [Staudinger, Anne] Attack error by Wachtel,Erin.
CARTHAGE [Staudinger, Anne] Service error. 4 Illinois Wesleyan 2
IWU 4 Carthage 3 [Schweigert, Kinzie] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
-- CARTHAGE subs: Heuermann, Emily.
-- IWU subs: Sabino,Sydney.
CARTHAGE [Fields, Rachel] Attack error by Fields, Rachel. 5 Illinois Wesleyan 3
-- CARTHAGE subs: Domalewski, Anna.
IWU 5 Carthage 4 [Howard,Morgan] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 5 Carthage 5 [Hailey, Bria] Kill by Chin, Karen (from Hailey, Bria).
CARTHAGE 5 Carthage 6 [Hailey, Bria] Service ace (Sabino,Sydney).
CARTHAGE 5 Carthage 7 [Hailey, Bria] Kill by Heuermann, Emily (from Hailey, Bria).
-- Timeout Illinois Wesleyan.
CARTHAGE 5 Carthage 8 [Hailey, Bria] Attack error by Wachtel,Erin.
CARTHAGE [Hailey, Bria] Kill by Wachtel,Erin (from Stenson, Morgan). 6 Illinois Wesleyan 8
IWU [Wachtel,Erin] Service ace (Domalewski, Anna). 7 Illinois Wesleyan 8
IWU [Wachtel,Erin] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Bruer, Lauren). 8 Illinois Wesleyan 8
IWU 8 Carthage 9 [Wachtel,Erin] Kill by Mickey, Rachel (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 8 Carthage 10 [Chin, Karen] Attack error by Knowels, Emily (block by Heuermann, Emily; Mickey, Rachel).
CARTHAGE 8 Carthage 11 [Chin, Karen] Kill by Heuermann, Emily (from Chin, Karen).
-- IWU subs: Thalmann,Miya.
CARTHAGE [Chin, Karen] Kill by Bruer, Lauren (from Thalmann,Miya). 9 Illinois Wesleyan 11
-- IWU subs: Schweigert, Kinzie.
IWU [Greybar,Maddie] Attack error by Domalewski, Anna. 10 Illinois Wesleyan 11
IWU 10 Carthage 12 [Greybar,Maddie] Kill by Mickey, Rachel (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 10 Carthage 13 [Shumaker, Sara] Attack error by Stenson, Morgan.
CARTHAGE [Shumaker, Sara] Kill by Knowels, Emily. 11 Illinois Wesleyan 13
IWU 11 Carthage 14 [Bruer, Lauren] Service error.
CARTHAGE 11 Carthage 15 Point awarded by official to Carthage.
CARTHAGE 11 Carthage 16 Point awarded by official to Carthage.
CARTHAGE 11 Carthage 17 [Cahoon, Hanna] Attack error by Schweigert, Kinzie.
-- Timeout Illinois Wesleyan.
CARTHAGE 11 Carthage 18 [Cahoon, Hanna] Service ace (Bruer, Lauren).
CARTHAGE 11 Carthage 19 [Cahoon, Hanna] Service ace (Greybar,Maddie).
CARTHAGE [Cahoon, Hanna] Kill by Schweigert, Kinzie (from Wachtel,Erin). 12 Illinois Wesleyan 19
IWU 12 Carthage 20 [Stenson, Morgan] Service error.
CARTHAGE [Staudinger, Anne] Attack error by Hailey, Bria. 13 Illinois Wesleyan 20
IWU 13 Carthage 21 [Stenson, Morgan] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE [Fields, Rachel] Kill by Howard,Morgan (from Wachtel,Erin). 14 Illinois Wesleyan 21
-- CARTHAGE subs: Domalewski, Anna.
IWU 14 Carthage 22 [Howard,Morgan] Service error.
CARTHAGE 14 Carthage 23 [Hailey, Bria] Kill by Staudinger, Anne (from Chin, Karen).
-- IWU subs: Hawk,Lizzy.
CARTHAGE [Hailey, Bria] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Wachtel,Erin). 15 Illinois Wesleyan 23
-- IWU subs: Stenson, Morgan.
IWU 15 Carthage 24 [Wachtel,Erin] Attack error by Stenson, Morgan (block by Mickey, Rachel).
CARTHAGE 15 Carthage 25 [Chin, Karen] Attack error by Greybar,Maddie.

Set #2 Plays

Set #2 Plays
Serve Team IWU - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score CARTHAGE - Play Description
IWU [Hawk,Lizzy] Service ace (Fields, Rachel). 1 Illinois Wesleyan 0
IWU 1 Carthage 1 [Hawk,Lizzy] Attack error by Hawk,Lizzy.
IWU 1 Carthage 2 [Hawk,Lizzy] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 1 Carthage 3 [Fields, Rachel] Attack error by Greybar,Maddie.
CARTHAGE 1 Carthage 4 [Fields, Rachel] Attack error by Howard,Morgan.
CARTHAGE [Fields, Rachel] Kill by Knowels, Emily (from Bruer, Lauren). 2 Illinois Wesleyan 4
IWU 2 Carthage 5 [Sabino,Sydney] Kill by Heuermann, Emily (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE [Hailey, Bria] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Wachtel,Erin). 3 Illinois Wesleyan 5
-- IWU subs: Stenson, Morgan.
IWU [Wachtel,Erin] Attack error by Heuermann, Emily. 4 Illinois Wesleyan 5
-- CARTHAGE subs: Heuermann, Emily.
IWU 4 Carthage 6 [Wachtel,Erin] Kill by Mickey, Rachel (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE [Chin, Karen] Kill by Stenson, Morgan (from Wachtel,Erin). 5 Illinois Wesleyan 6
IWU [Greybar,Maddie] Service ace (Chin, Karen). 6 Illinois Wesleyan 6
IWU [Wachtel,Erin] Kill by Schweigert, Kinzie (from Stenson, Morgan). 7 Illinois Wesleyan 6
IWU 7 Carthage 7 [Greybar,Maddie] Kill by Mickey, Rachel (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE [Shumaker, Sara] Kill by Knowels, Emily (from Wachtel,Erin), block error by Staudinger, Anne. 8 Illinois Wesleyan 7
IWU 8 Carthage 8 [Bruer, Lauren] Kill by Staudinger, Anne (from Cahoon, Hanna).
CARTHAGE 8 Carthage 9 [Cahoon, Hanna] Service ace (Greybar,Maddie).
CARTHAGE [Cahoon, Hanna] Attack error by Staudinger, Anne. 9 Illinois Wesleyan 9
IWU [Stenson, Morgan] Attack error by Staudinger, Anne. 10 Illinois Wesleyan 9
IWU [Stenson, Morgan] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Stenson, Morgan). 11 Illinois Wesleyan 9
IWU 11 Carthage 10 [Stenson, Morgan] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
-- IWU subs: Hawk,Lizzy.
CARTHAGE [Staudinger, Anne] Kill by Howard,Morgan (from Wachtel,Erin). 12 Illinois Wesleyan 10
IWU 12 Carthage 11 [Schweigert, Kinzie] Service error.
-- IWU subs: Sabino,Sydney.
-- CARTHAGE subs: Heuermann, Emily.
CARTHAGE 12 Carthage 12 [Fields, Rachel] Attack error by Bruer, Lauren.
CARTHAGE [Fields, Rachel] Kill by Howard,Morgan (from Wachtel,Erin). 13 Illinois Wesleyan 12
-- CARTHAGE subs: Domalewski, Anna.
IWU [Howard,Morgan] Attack error by Heuermann, Emily. 14 Illinois Wesleyan 12
IWU 14 Carthage 13 [Howard,Morgan] Attack error by Greybar,Maddie (block by Chin, Karen; Heuermann, Emily).
CARTHAGE [Hailey, Bria] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Wachtel,Erin). 15 Illinois Wesleyan 13
-- IWU subs: Stenson, Morgan.
IWU [Wachtel,Erin] Kill by Knowels, Emily. 16 Illinois Wesleyan 13
-- Timeout Carthage.
IWU 16 Carthage 14 [Wachtel,Erin] Kill by Mickey, Rachel (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE [Chin, Karen] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Wachtel,Erin). 17 Illinois Wesleyan 14
-- IWU subs: Schweigert, Kinzie.
IWU 17 Carthage 15 [Greybar,Maddie] Kill by Cahoon, Hanna (from Chin, Karen).
-- CARTHAGE subs: Shumaker, Sara; Fields, Rachel.
CARTHAGE 17 Carthage 16 [Shumaker, Sara] Kill by Mickey, Rachel (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE [Shumaker, Sara] Kill by Stenson, Morgan (from Wachtel,Erin). 18 Illinois Wesleyan 16
IWU 18 Carthage 17 [Bruer, Lauren] Attack error by Greybar,Maddie.
CARTHAGE 18 Carthage 18 [Cahoon, Hanna] Attack error by Howard,Morgan.
CARTHAGE 18 Carthage 19 [Cahoon, Hanna] Kill by Staudinger, Anne (from Chin, Karen).
-- Timeout Illinois Wesleyan.
CARTHAGE 18 Carthage 20 [Cahoon, Hanna] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 18 Carthage 21 [Cahoon, Hanna] Attack error by Howard,Morgan.
CARTHAGE 18 Carthage 22 [Cahoon, Hanna] Kill by Staudinger, Anne (from Chin, Karen).
-- Timeout Illinois Wesleyan.
CARTHAGE [Cahoon, Hanna] Kill by Schweigert, Kinzie (from Wachtel,Erin). 19 Illinois Wesleyan 22
IWU 19 Carthage 23 [Stenson, Morgan] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
-- IWU subs: Hawk,Lizzy.
CARTHAGE [Staudinger, Anne] Kill by Howard,Morgan (from Wachtel,Erin). 20 Illinois Wesleyan 23
IWU 20 Carthage 24 [Schweigert, Kinzie] Kill by Staudinger, Anne (from Chin, Karen).
-- IWU subs: Sabino,Sydney.
-- CARTHAGE subs: Heuermann, Emily.
CARTHAGE 20 Carthage 25 [Fields, Rachel] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).

Set #3 Plays

Set #3 Plays
Serve Team IWU - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score CARTHAGE - Play Description
CARTHAGE 0 Carthage 1 [Cahoon, Hanna] Service ace (Bruer, Lauren).
-- CARTHAGE subs: Cahoon, Hanna.
-- IWU subs: Bruer, Lauren.
CARTHAGE 0 Carthage 2 [Cahoon, Hanna] Kill by Chin, Karen (from Fields, Rachel).
CARTHAGE [Cahoon, Hanna] Attack error by Fields, Rachel. 1 Illinois Wesleyan 2
IWU 1 Carthage 3 [Stenson, Morgan] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
-- IWU subs: Cornish, Alexa.
CARTHAGE [Staudinger, Anne] Service error. 2 Illinois Wesleyan 3
IWU 2 Carthage 4 [Schweigert, Kinzie] Kill by Staudinger, Anne (from Chin, Karen).
-- CARTHAGE subs: Heuermann, Emily.
-- IWU subs: Sabino,Sydney.
CARTHAGE [Fields, Rachel] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Wachtel,Erin). 3 Illinois Wesleyan 4
-- CARTHAGE subs: Domalewski, Anna.
IWU 3 Carthage 5 [Howard,Morgan] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 3 Carthage 6 [Hailey, Bria] Attack error by Knowels, Emily.
CARTHAGE 3 Carthage 7 [Hailey, Bria] Attack error by Greybar,Maddie.
CARTHAGE [Hailey, Bria] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Wachtel,Erin). 4 Illinois Wesleyan 7
-- IWU subs: Stenson, Morgan.
IWU [Wachtel,Erin] Attack error by Staudinger, Anne. 5 Illinois Wesleyan 7
IWU 5 Carthage 8 [Wachtel,Erin] Kill by Heuermann, Emily (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 5 Carthage 9 [Chin, Karen] Attack error by Greybar,Maddie.
CARTHAGE 5 Carthage 10 [Chin, Karen] Attack error by Knowels, Emily.
-- Timeout Illinois Wesleyan.
CARTHAGE [Chin, Karen] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Wachtel,Erin). 6 Illinois Wesleyan 10
-- IWU subs: Schweigert, Kinzie.
IWU 6 Carthage 11 [Greybar,Maddie] Attack error by Stenson, Morgan.
-- CARTHAGE subs: Shumaker, Sara; Fields, Rachel.
CARTHAGE 6 Carthage 12 [Shumaker, Sara] Attack error by Schweigert, Kinzie.
CARTHAGE [Shumaker, Sara] Kill by Schweigert, Kinzie (from Wachtel,Erin). 7 Illinois Wesleyan 12
IWU 7 Carthage 13 [Bruer, Lauren] Kill by Fields, Rachel (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 7 Carthage 14 [Cahoon, Hanna] Ball handling error by Wachtel,Erin.
CARTHAGE 7 Carthage 15 [Cahoon, Hanna] Attack error by Stenson, Morgan.
-- IWU subs: Adams,Tara.
CARTHAGE 7 Carthage 16 [Cahoon, Hanna] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen), block error by Howard,Morgan.
-- Timeout Illinois Wesleyan.
CARTHAGE [Cahoon, Hanna] Service error. 8 Illinois Wesleyan 16
IWU 8 Carthage 17 [Adams,Tara] Kill by Fields, Rachel (from Chin, Karen).
-- IWU subs: Cornish, Alexa.
CARTHAGE 8 Carthage 18 [Staudinger, Anne] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 8 Carthage 19 [Staudinger, Anne] Service ace (Cornish, Alexa).
-- IWU subs: Udelhofen,Sarah.
CARTHAGE 8 Carthage 20 [Staudinger, Anne] Attack error by Howard,Morgan.
CARTHAGE 8 Carthage 21 [Staudinger, Anne] Kill by Staudinger, Anne (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE 8 Carthage 22 [Staudinger, Anne] Kill by Hailey, Bria (from Chin, Karen).
CARTHAGE [Staudinger, Anne] Kill by Wachtel,Erin (from Bruer, Lauren). 9 Illinois Wesleyan 22
IWU 9 Carthage 23 [Bruer, Lauren] Kill by Fields, Rachel (from Chin, Karen).
-- CARTHAGE subs: Heuermann, Emily.
-- IWU subs: Sabino,Sydney.
CARTHAGE 9 Carthage 24 [Fields, Rachel] Service ace (Bruer, Lauren).
CARTHAGE [Fields, Rachel] Kill by Greybar,Maddie (from Wachtel,Erin). 10 Illinois Wesleyan 24
-- CARTHAGE subs: Domalewski, Anna.
IWU 10 Carthage 25 [Howard,Morgan] Attack error by Wachtel,Erin.