| 1995 | Tony Curatolo, midfielder Mike Domin, forward Ben Gramke, midfielder |
| 1996 | Paul Bruni, defender Matt Cherney, goalkeeper Greg Dirkse, defender Mike Domin, forward Brad O'Sullivan, forward Bart Pryputniewicz, forward |
| 1997 | Matt Cherney, goalkeeper Mike Domin, forward Brent Malmstrom, midfielder Andy Mogg, defender |
| 1998 | Brent Malmstrom, first team, midfielder Bart Pryputniewicz, first team, forward Tim Burke, second team, midfielder |
| 1999 | Jon Purcell, first team, midfielder Brent Malmstrom, second team, midfielder Andy Mogg, second team, defender |
| 2000 | Brent Malmstrom, first team, midfielder Jon Purcell, second team, forward |
| 2001 | Jon Purcell, second team, midfielder Jay Sikorski, second team, defender |
| 2002 | Mike Brown, second team, defender B.J. Seward, second team, midfielder |
| 2003 | Jay Sikorski, second team, defender Max Zbilut, second team, forward |
| 2004 | Drew Baker, second team, goalkeeper Mike Brown, second team, defender |
| 2005 | Drew Baker, second team, goalkeeper Mike Brown, second team, defender |
| 2006 | Max Zbilut, first team, midfielder Andy Connor, second team, goalkeeper Chris Fidlow, second team, midfielder Pat Walsh, second team, defender |
| 2007 | Brian Santella, first team, forward Pat Walsh, first team, defender Andy Connor, second team, goalkeeper Chris Fidlow, second team, midfielder Greg Goldsberry, second team, forward |
| 2008 | Andy Connor, second team, goalkeeper Tyler Cortez, second team, forward Chris Fidlow, second team, midfielder |
| 2009 | Aleks Urosevic, second team, midfielder |
| 2010 | Aleks Urosevic, first team, forward Zak Khoshbin, second team, defender Tyler Peterson, second team, midfielder Greg Pignataro, second team, midfielder |
| 2011 | Billy Hamilton, first team, midfielder Zak Khoshbin, first team, defender Milan Tijanic, first team, goalkeeper Michael Dombrowski, second team, forward Greg Pignataro, second team, midfielder |
| 2012 | Michael Dombrowski, first team, forward Will Veliz, first team, defender Jordan Innis, second team, forward Greg Pignataro, second team, midfielder Milan Tijanic, second team, goalkeeper |
| 2013 | Michael Dombrowski, first team, forward Ryan Crane, second team, midfielder Billy Hamilton, second team, midfielder Taylor Pignataro, second team, midfielder |
| 2014 | Michael Dombrowski, second team, forward Taylor Pignataro, second team, defender Arnoldo Reyes, second team, midfielder |
| 2015 | Ivan Chavez, first team, midfielder Giles Phillips, first team, defender Johnny Rimkus, first team, forward Austin Bitta, second team, midfielder |