Eight members of the Carthage team were named 2012 All-Midwest Men's Lacrosse Conference.  Defender Andrew Bellville (Sr., Deer Park, Ill./Lake Zurich, 43 caused turnovers) and attackman Keegan Bowman (Sr., New Westminster, British Columbia/New Westminster Secondary, 50 goals, 18 assists, 48 ground balls, 11 caused turnovers) were named first-team All-MMLC. 

Defender Dustin Heinrichs (Sr., Wausau, Wis./West, 23 ground balls, 48 caused turnovers), long stick midfielder Rusty Miller (Sr., Pacific Palisades, Calif./Charter, 37 ground balls, 25 caused turnovers) and attackman Seth Molek (Jr., Oak Park, Ill./Oak Park-River Forest, 34 goals, 26 assists, 24 ground balls) were named second-team all-conference.  Goalkeeper Spencer Curley (Sr., Naperville, Ill./Neuqua Valley, 6.59 goals-against average, 123 saves), midfielder Danny Morse (O'Fallon, Ill./O'Fallon Township, 21 goals, 10 assists, 18 ground balls) and face-off man Dylan Delaney (Fr., Savage, Minn./Burnsville, 156-271) earned honorable mention all-conference honors.