Six Carthage College players were named 2011 All-Midwest Men's Lacrosse Conference. Defender Andrew Bellville (Jr., Deer Park, Ill./Lake Zurich, 42 ground balls) and attackman Keegan Bowman (Jr., New Westminster, British Columbia, 39 goals, 37 assists, 33 ground balls) were named first-team All-MMLC.

Attackman Cory Childs (Sr., Savage, Minn./Prior Lake, 48 goals, 12 assists, 37 ground balls), goalkeeper Spencer Curley (Jr., Naperville, Ill./Neuqua Valley, 6.49 goals-against average, 124 saves), defender Dustin Heinrichs (Jr., Wausau, Wis./West, 9 ground balls) and midfielder Danny Morse (Fr., O'Fallon, Ill./O'Fallon Township, 35 goals, 30 assists, 42 ground balls) earned second-team all-conference honors. Additionally, Morse was named “newcomer of the year.”

Anderson Morgan from the College of Mount St. Joseph was named “player of the year,” and Aurora University's Brendan Dawson earned “coach of the year” honors.